Aukerman's involvement with the Earwolf Challenge lead to him crossing paths with Tommy and Karl, who came second in the competition.
His first appearance on The Little Dum Dum Club to date was the 56th episode of the show, the final of three episodes of the podcast recorded in America. The other two guests were Paul F. Tompkins and Matt Besser. The episode was posted on the 26th of October, 2011; exactly one year after the very first episode. In December 2012, Aukerman returned to the show while Tommy and Karl were visiting Los Angeles for the 115th episode. The episode also featured long-time friend of the show Nick Cody.